Last entry I made, I said "even odder is the weird flashes of feeling like a good Christian that accompany [me giving change to panhandlers]".
lucki_dog then asked me: "Why "Good Christian"? Why can't you just feel like a "Good Person" and not get wigged out by it? Christians are surely not the only good people on the planet, and I would venture a wager that a fair portion of them aren't even 'good'. /mini-rant" I think the issue (and my response) deserves an entry of its own.
To begin at the end: I in no way meant to imply that only Christians are/can be good people, nor that all Christians are 'good'. That would be asinine in the extreme, and would place me on the same level as, say, Pat Robertson. Y'all know me better than that; my Christianity is somewhat tenuous to begin with, so it wouldn't make much sense to elevate it above all else as a paragon of [chauvinist] virtue.
But that brings me to the first point. Could I feel like a good person (no religion specified)? Sure I could, but that's reversing cause and effect. The whole point is that I didn't feel like a good person, I felt like a good Christian. I think everybody's mind works similarly to mine (that's what psycholinguistics teaches me, at least), but just in case somebody out there is different, let me explain: I live in a highly allusive world. Everything I see/hear/touch/whatever brings with it myriad associations, and those associations form the framework upon which my worldview rests. Most everybody does this; it's what gives multi-level meaning to our words and our actions. So the thing is, almsgiving doesn't just give me some vague warm fuzzy of a feeling, it brings up not only certain images and emotions but even specific texts. In this case my mind presented me with Jesus' injunction to "get up and follow me", the assertion that it is harder for a rich man to go to heaven than for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle, and some less specific concepts of monastic vows of poverty. Do you get it? I didn't just feel like a good person, tout court, I felt like a good Christian, following in the steps of Jesus.
That's weird for me, it really is. I was raised Christian, and to a certain extent, I remain one, but the Church is no longer my main referential beacon (hell, I'm not entirely certain it ever was). In the past 6 years or so, my entire take on religion has become much more broad and ecumenical. While the figure of Jesus is still a powerful one for me, I also find myself thinking in terms that are more commonly Jewish and neopagan. My religion doesn't center around a Crucified Savior anymore, it centers more on a less corporeal but more personal God who takes on countless forms. So I think it quite understandable that I was surprised to be pleased by my actions insofar as they reflected a distinctly Christian ideal, not a broader humanist one. Not upset, mind you, and not exclusively moral, but definitely surprised.
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
To begin at the end: I in no way meant to imply that only Christians are/can be good people, nor that all Christians are 'good'. That would be asinine in the extreme, and would place me on the same level as, say, Pat Robertson. Y'all know me better than that; my Christianity is somewhat tenuous to begin with, so it wouldn't make much sense to elevate it above all else as a paragon of [chauvinist] virtue.
But that brings me to the first point. Could I feel like a good person (no religion specified)? Sure I could, but that's reversing cause and effect. The whole point is that I didn't feel like a good person, I felt like a good Christian. I think everybody's mind works similarly to mine (that's what psycholinguistics teaches me, at least), but just in case somebody out there is different, let me explain: I live in a highly allusive world. Everything I see/hear/touch/whatever brings with it myriad associations, and those associations form the framework upon which my worldview rests. Most everybody does this; it's what gives multi-level meaning to our words and our actions. So the thing is, almsgiving doesn't just give me some vague warm fuzzy of a feeling, it brings up not only certain images and emotions but even specific texts. In this case my mind presented me with Jesus' injunction to "get up and follow me", the assertion that it is harder for a rich man to go to heaven than for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle, and some less specific concepts of monastic vows of poverty. Do you get it? I didn't just feel like a good person, tout court, I felt like a good Christian, following in the steps of Jesus.
That's weird for me, it really is. I was raised Christian, and to a certain extent, I remain one, but the Church is no longer my main referential beacon (hell, I'm not entirely certain it ever was). In the past 6 years or so, my entire take on religion has become much more broad and ecumenical. While the figure of Jesus is still a powerful one for me, I also find myself thinking in terms that are more commonly Jewish and neopagan. My religion doesn't center around a Crucified Savior anymore, it centers more on a less corporeal but more personal God who takes on countless forms. So I think it quite understandable that I was surprised to be pleased by my actions insofar as they reflected a distinctly Christian ideal, not a broader humanist one. Not upset, mind you, and not exclusively moral, but definitely surprised.